How the doubts began
For more than two centuries after his death, nobody seriously questioned that Shakespeare wrote his plays. In the 1850s, as the Romantic worship of Shakespeare as a transcendent genius reached its height, some writers found it hard to believe that a glover's son from a market town, without a university education, could have written them. The American writer Delia Bacon argued in 1857 that the plays were the work of a group led by Francis Bacon and Sir Walter Raleigh.
The alternative candidates
Francis Bacon (1561–1626), philosopher and statesman, was the favourite candidate of the 19th century. His supporters searched the plays for hidden ciphers.
Edward de Vere, 17th Earl of Oxford (1550–1604), a courtier and poet, was proposed by J. Thomas Looney in 1920 and is now the most popular alternative. The obvious difficulty is that Oxford died in 1604, before about ten of the plays, including King Lear, Macbeth and The Tempest, are generally thought to have been written. Supporters argue for earlier dates.
Christopher Marlowe (1564–1593), the brilliant playwright, was killed in a tavern in Deptford in 1593. His candidacy requires his death to have been faked.
Other suggestions have included William Stanley, 6th Earl of Derby, and Mary Sidney, Countess of Pembroke.
The evidence for Shakespeare
- His name appears on the title pages of his poems and of many plays published in his lifetime, and he was named as a playwright by contemporaries such as Francis Meres in 1598.
- The First Folio was compiled by two actors who had worked with him for decades, and it includes tributes from Ben Jonson, who knew him well and identified him as the 'Sweet Swan of Avon'.
- His monument in Holy Trinity Church, in place by 1623, compares him to great classical writers and shows him with a pen.
- Records show him as an actor and sharer in the company that performed the plays, and his will leaves money to fellow actors Burbage, Heminges and Condell.
- Stylistic and linguistic studies show that several plays were co-written with identifiable playwrights, such as Fletcher, Middleton, Peele and Wilkins: the normal working practice of a professional theatre writer, which fits Shakespeare, not a secretive aristocrat.
- A passage in the manuscript of the play Sir Thomas More, in a hand known as 'Hand D', is widely believed to be in Shakespeare's handwriting.
The education argument
A common argument is that the plays show knowledge of law, the classics, foreign countries and court life that a man of Shakespeare's background could not have had. Historians reply that the Elizabethan grammar school gave a demanding classical education; that Shakespeare worked for decades in London among lawyers, courtiers and writers; that his company performed regularly at court; and that most of his knowledge came from books that can be identified, such as Holinshed, Plutarch and Ovid. His plays also contain errors, like the coast of Bohemia, that a widely travelled aristocrat would be unlikely to make.
The debate continues outside universities, and its supporters have included famous names. But no document from Shakespeare's lifetime suggests that anyone else wrote his works.
Read next
- Biography
The documented life
- The First Folio
The book his colleagues made
Sources and further reading
Facts on this page were checked against the collections and research published by these organisations. They are the best places to go deeper.